Written By Heather King

When the smell of autumn is in the air and the Wasatch mountains glow with autumn colors, Utahns know that it’s time to celebrate fall. And while pumpkin spice might be an easy go-to, it isn’t everyone’s cup of tea. That’s why we’ve created the Utah Fall Gifting Guide, highlighting local flavors and cozy comforts that make autumn gifting truly special.

Coffee Treats

Skip the pumpkin spice latte and a bag of locally roasted coffee paired with our handcrafted Brew toffee. Our buttery toffee layered with dark chocolate and hazelnuts captures the warm and comforting feeling of fall in every bite. Pair it with local honey or apple butter from Utah’s farms for a gift that feels warm and personal.

Cozy Comforts

Nothing says or tastes like fall more than Summit. Suggest snuggling with a soft throw from a Utah artisan, lighting hand-poured soy candles in woodsy scents, and opening a box of Summit to embrace the season’s slower pace. These thoughtful pieces remind loved ones of the beauty of fall.

Caramel Cravings

Few treats capture Utah’s autumn magic quite like Cache Toffee’s Tartan Turtle and caramel apples. Assemble a DIY caramel apple gift basket that features fresh, crisp apples from local orchards, along with dipping caramel and Tartan Turtle toffee that you can crush and roll your caramel apples in. Each bite balances the tart crunch of apple with the sweetness of caramel, layered with the rich, nutty depth of toffee. It’s perfect for an evening after a fall hike, a Halloween party activity, or simply treating your family to some delicious fun on a cool afternoon. Caramel apples are fall’s sweetest tradition after all!

Gifts for Gatherings

Fall is all about connection—family dinners, tailgates, and evenings by the fire. Create a Utah-inspired gift basket featuring Cache Toffee Party Popcorn, a selection of local cider or beer, and artisanal cheeses from your favorite Utah creamery. It’s the perfect way to elevate any gathering while supporting local makers.

Why Cache Toffee is Worth Gifting

Our toffee is made in small batches, ensuring a perfect buttery crunch and smooth, melt-in-your-mouth finish. Whatever flavor you choose to share, Cache Toffee brings warmth, flavor, and a touch of whimsy to a seasonal gift. 

So, this season, take a page from our fall gifting guide and share some of Utah’s tastiest culture to celebrate the season. Whether it’s a hostess gift, a thank you, or just a sweet surprise, choosing thoughtful, locally inspired items ensures your gesture stands out—without a hint of pumpkin spice.