Written By Heather King

Few things feel as indulgent as sitting down with a glass of wine and your favorite Cache Toffee. The handcrafted, buttery goodness of our toffee, paired with bold layers of flavor, is a tasting experience in itself, but when thoughtfully paired with wine, each bite and sip can elevate the other, creating delicious moments.

Whether you’re sipping bold reds, crisp whites, delicate rosés, or festive bubbles, here’s how to perfectly pair your wine with your favorite Cache Toffee flavor. 

Red Wine with Cache Toffee

Best Pairings: Cabernet Sauvignon, Merlot, Zinfandel

Red wines are all about richness, boldness, and depth—qualities that beautifully complement toffee’s buttery and sometimes nutty flavors.

• Traditional Cache Toffee: Its smooth, buttery caramel notes are a dream with a glass of Cabernet Sauvignon. The wine’s dark fruit and tannins cut through the sweetness, creating a luxurious balance.
• Traditional Dark Cache Toffee: This toffee features artisan dark chocolate from Madagascar, so pair it with a bold Zinfandel. The wine’s jammy berry flavors and spice highlight the slight fruitiness of the chocolate, making each bite and sip more intense.
• Brew Cache Toffee: A Merlot, with its velvety texture and hints of plum and chocolate, perfectly echoes the rich coffee notes, rounding out with soft, fruity undertones.

Serving tip: Serve your red wines slightly cooler than room temperature (around 60–65°F) for the best experience!

White Wine and Cache Toffee

Best Pairings: Riesling, Sauvignon Blanc

White wines offer a refreshing contrast to toffee’s decadent sweetness, often bringing notes of citrus, green apple, or tropical fruits that brighten the palate.

• Summit Cache Toffee: Try this with a slightly off-dry Riesling. The nutty, dry-roasted, and lightly salted flavors of the pistachios, pumpkin seeds, and sunflower seeds in this toffee harmonize with the Riesling’s vibrant acidity and hint of sweetness. 
• Blondie Cache Toffee: A crisp Sauvignon Blanc, with its grassy, tropical notes, mirrors the toffee’s mango-ginger island flair, making each bite feel like a beach vacation in a glass.

Serving tip: Chill white wines to approximately 45–50°F, but remove them from the fridge a few minutes before serving to allow the flavors to open up.

Rosé and Cache Toffee

Best Pairings: Dry Rosé, Sparkling Rosé

Rosé sits beautifully between the worlds of red and white, offering fruitiness with a refreshing acidity that complements many Cache Toffee flavors.

• Tartan Turtle Cache Toffee: A dry, berry-scented Rosé brings out the earthy, buttery depth of whole-roasted pecans and cashews without overwhelming the palate. It’s an effortlessly elegant match.
• Tango Cache Toffee or some of our seasonal flavors: Pair spicy toffees with a richer, fuller-bodied Rosé to complement the warmth without making the pairing too heavy.

Serving tip: For outdoor events or summer sipping, a chilled Rosé and a platter of Cache Toffee make a stunning and simple dessert option.

Bubbles with Cache Toffee

Best Pairings: Brut Champagne, Prosecco, Cava

Sparkling wines are perfect for celebrations—and as fabulous flavor enhancers, too. The effervescence of bubbles cuts through the richness of toffee, keeping your palate refreshed and ready for more.

• Key Cache Toffee and Party Popcorn: A classic Brut Champagne brings bright citrus, green apple, and yeasty notes that provide an elegant counterpoint to the sweet, buttery toffee.
• Traditional Cache Toffee and Milk Chocolates: Prosecco’s softer bubbles and hints of pear and peach pair lusciously with milk chocolate, creating a pairing that’s playful and indulgent.
• Limited Edition Holiday Flavors: For seasonal flavors with a hint of spice and warmth, try a Spanish Cava. Its crisp acidity and slight earthiness ground the toffee’s festive spices without overpowering them.

Serving tip: Serve bubbles well-chilled (around 40–45°F) and keep a few extra bottles on hand—you’ll need them once guests taste how perfectly they pair with Cache Toffee!

Savor the Perfect Pairing

When you pair Cache Toffee with the right wine, the experience transcends simple sweetness, offering complex layers of flavors for unmatched enjoyment.

As you’re putting together a dessert board or searching for a memorable hostess gift, think beyond the usual and create a Cache Toffee and wine pairing moment. Your taste buds will thank you for these sweet pairings. Cheers!