Sometimes, it’s not just about what you give to show you care—it’s how it’s given. While Cache Toffee is known for its small-batch quality and handcrafted flavors, the story of one Texas couple exemplifies what makes our toffee truly special: the personal connection behind every order.

Creating a Lasting Memory

Some time ago, a woman from Texas was visiting Salt Lake City on a business trip. She and her husband had tried Cache Toffee before and loved it, and she wanted to surprise him with something meaningful when she returned home. So, she placed an order for Cache Toffee, intent on bringing a lasting memory and a little piece of Utah home to her husband.

But this wasn’t just any order. When Lori Darr, the founder of Cache Toffee, saw the delivery details, she didn’t hesitate to add a personal touch. She hand-delivered the beautifully packaged toffee to the woman’s hotel in downtown Salt Lake City. It was a small gesture, but one that made the gift feel truly personal—an experience the woman later described as “above and beyond.”

The best part? Her husband was thrilled when she returned home. That thoughtful surprise became more than a sweet gift—it was a reminder of a shared memory, of time spent together in Utah, and of the kind of thoughtfulness that turns customers into friends. Since then, the couple have become loyal Cache Toffee fans, regularly ordering from Texas and sending our toffee as gifts to others.

This story captures so much of what we love about our product and brand:

• Every batch of handmade toffee is cooked in small batches with the highest-quality ingredients, including rich butter, premium chocolate, and perfectly roasted nuts.
• Lori and the team personally care about every order and every recipient—whether it’s across town or across the country.
• With 11 flavors to choose from, there’s something perfect for every palate, from classic Traditional to Tartan Turtle.
• With insulated packaging and careful shipping methods, even summer orders to warm-weather states like Texas arrive fresh and ready to enjoy, so you can confidently gift it year-round.

Give a Sweet Gift of Handmade Toffee

At Cache Toffee, every bite tells a story—one of thoughtfulness, craftsmanship, and genuine care. Whether you’re looking for a gift that travels well, a way to share a taste of Utah with someone far away, or something heartfelt for your next event or client gift, Cache Toffee delivers the sweetest gift. From birthdays and anniversaries to wedding favors and out-of-state care packages to everyday surprises, our handmade toffee says you went the extra mile to choose something special in the sweetest way possible.